NBA All time fantasy Season game 6 BNB vs. Clone

[CODE_BLUE56]

BNB's roster

Spoiler

Starters:

PG: Magic Johnson [86-87: 24 PPG, 12 APG, 6 RPG] 40 Min.
SG: George Gervin [79-80: 33 PPG, 5 RPG, 2.6 APG] 35 min.
SF: Alex English [82-83: 28.4 PPG, 7 RPG, 5 APG] 30 min.
PF: Moses Malone [81-82: 31 PPG, 14.7 RPG] 38 min.
C: David Robinson [90-91: 25.6 PPG, 13 RPG, 4.0 BPG] 38 min.

Bench:

PG: Mark Price [89-90: 19.6 PPG, 9 APG] 5 min.
SG: Chris Mullin [88-89: 26.5 PPG, 6 RPG, 5 APG] 13 min.
SF: Shawn Marion [05-06: 22 PPG, 12 RPG] 18 min.
PF: Pau Gasol [06-07: 21 PPG, 10 RPG, 3.4 APG, 2 BPG] 8 min.
C: Dikembe Mutombo [94-95: 11.5 PPG, 12.5 RPG, 4 BPG]
8 min.
-M.Camby [06-07: 11.2 PPG, 11.7 RPG, 3.3 BPG] 4 min
-S.Marbury [00-01: 24 PPG 7.6 APG] 3 min.

clone's roster

Spoiler

Starters:
PG-98-99 Jason Kidd (40min)
SG-96-97 Mitch Richmond (30min)
SF-74-75 Rick Barry (40min)
PF-01-02 Tim Duncan (35min)
C-99-00 Shaquille O'Neal (38min)

Bench:
PG-95-96 Anfernee "Penny" Hardaway (13min)
SG-77-78 David Thompson (10min)
SF-09-10 Gerald Wallace (8min)
PF-05-06 Elton Brand (10min)
C-78-79 Artis Gilmore (10min)
SG/SF-99-00 Michael Finley (5min)
PF/C-72-73 Spencer Haywood (8min)

who wins?

make yer case

[clonetrooper264]

PG- Well Magic is the best PG ever, but since he's not much of a defender, Kidd is not neutralized.
SG- Scoring fest. I'd take Richmond's defense over Gervin's, but regardless they're just going to light each other up.
SF- English is really just a scorer. Barry is also a scorer...but a better one. They have similar rebounding and assist numbers so that doesn't affect much.
PF- Moses is definitely a beast, but Duncan isn't the best PF for no reason. He'd have his hands full, but he could handle it.
C- Shaq outmuscles Robinson in a tough matchup.
Bench-BnB has a heck of a frontcourt. I'd take Gilmore over Mutumbo because his offense is far better and his defense isn't too far behind either. Gasol beats Brand, but could potentially "turn soft" with Brand constantly banging. Wallace and Marion cancel each other out. They have very similar stats and playing styles. Mullen and Thompson is another scoring fest. However, Mullen was a shooter as a scorer so he could have a bad night more often than Thompson. I think Penny's length bothers Price enough to hold him below his scoring average while dominating him on the offensive end with his height advantage. Haywood has a much better overall game than Camby.

BnB has a ton of scoring in that starting lineup, but there aren't enough shots for all of them, even if Magic is the distributing. Gervin was never much of a team player and would probably be unhappy with the number of shots he was getting. Marbury would be fuming at the end of the bench. I'd probably play Wallace more on English to take him out of the picture and use Barry to tire out Gervin. If necessary I could use Finley more instead of Thompson for more shooting and defense. It'd be a close matchup, but I think I can pull away with better team play.