List Your Top And Bottom Kenny Williams Trades

[DewsSox79]

List Your Top And Bottom Kenny Williams Trades.

There has been debate on whether or not KW gives up too many spects for players etc, etc, so which ones did he win, which ones do you think he lost?

discuss!

 

[BigSoxHurt35]

Worst-Nick Swisher both acquiring and trading away
Best-Trading McCarthy and getting John Danks/Trade Mike Cameron for Paul Konerko

P.S. This Edwin Jackson kid keeps pitching like this and this could be one of his best

 

[nickofypres]

Best: Danks and Floyd deals
Worst: Anderson for Kotsay

Most Underrated trade: Garland for Cabrera. Gave us (at the time) a solid infield defense, got us a solid #2 hitter (since Iguchi was traded away at the 07' deadline). I still love the trade.

 

[DewsSox79]

Best: Danks and Floyd deals
Worst: Anderson for Kotsay

Most Underrated trade: Garland for Cabrera. Gave us (at the time) a solid infield defense, got us a solid #2 hitter (since Iguchi was traded away at the 07' deadline). I still love the trade.

Really? I hate Kotsay but Anderson couldnt even make the KC squad and is now pitching.

 

[BigSoxHurt35]

Ya hell Kotsays been better than anderson! HAHAH
Worst FA signing: Todd Ritchie

 

[nickofypres]

If Ozzie let Anderson get the at bats needed to develop to go with his glove he would of been very useful.

Even if Anderson ended up as the #9 hitter (which he probably would of) but had decent stats. He's a cheap, key guy. Instead he's benched for the greats of Mackowiak, Erstad, Wise, Owens.....

 

[BigSoxHurt35]

LMFAO i remember rob mackowiak

 

[BigSoxHurt35]

HAHA they just said on the sox game tonight Brian Anderson is now a pitcher for the Royals! Man he couldn't hit water if he fell out of a boat

 

[nickofypres]

Its a shame too. If handled right (see not by Ozzie) he could of been a decent enough player.

 

[Capt. Serious]

Best: McCarthy for Danks
Worst: Nick Swisher

Gave away Ryan Sweeney & Gio Gonzalez for him.

No wonder our farm system is so piss poor.

 

[GrinderBall41]

Best: McCarthy for Danks
Worst: Nick Swisher

Gave away Ryan Sweeney & Gio Gonzalez for him.

No wonder our farm system is so piss poor.

:shot: Ryan Sweeney and Gio Gonzalez are nothing special...

When I first read that I thought for sure you meant giving him to the Yanks for a bunch of crap... that was the bad trade. You do realize that Swisher is really good at baseball right?

So yeah worst Swish to Yanks
And best Thornton for Borchard

 

[Lefty]

Best: Getting rid of an over-hyped B-Mac for Danks.

Worst: Ray Durham to Oakland for Jon Adkins, Keith Foulke (and two others) to Oakland for Billy Kotch and Neal Cotts.

He loves to get fleeced by Billy Beane.

 

[DewsSox79]

Best: Getting rid of an over-hyped B-Mac for Danks.

Worst: Ray Durham to Oakland for Jon Adkins, Keith Foulke (and two others) to Oakland for Billy Kotch and Neal Cotts.

He loves to get fleeced by Billy Beane.

neal cotts was serviceable