- Joined:
- Aug 23, 2012
- Posts:
- 10,754
- Liked Posts:
- 3,518
Yes or no?
Would you trade Jay to the 49ers for Harbaugh and Kap
Does Kaplan look like a Footbaw player to you?
Yes or no?
I will expand on my no a little. I would trade Cutler, but not for Kap and Harbaugh. Kap is a highly paid, turnover machine as well. Why trade for that? Harbaugh is losing with that talented team. I would pass on both.
What?
Some key talent has been injured
Seems like a lot of our members are hitting the holiday hootch early
What?
Some key talent has been injured
What?
Some key talent has been injured
Uh, hell yes. I'll pass on a 31 year old overpaid qb who's had 10 years to prove what he can do at this level. Give me a coach who can turn a program around and been to 3 NFC championship games and the Super Bowl. And Jay has the Diubeeeetus and too many concussions and knee/ankle injuries. Kap has promise and can fetch what Jay would in a trade as well.
Sounds like excuses..
Most teams have key talent that is injured. Or in the case of the Cardinals, every player on their roster.
Yes, he 'turned around' the most talented roster in the NFL.
He's apparently also turned them around again. Turned them into a shitty undisciplined team who is out of the playoffs.
Thier offense is pretty healthy, and can't do shit. They lost some players on Defense, so has every team. He is a good coach, but he is being over-rated right now. Lovie was a good coach as well and he wasn't good enough for some here.
Lovie was never anywhere near as successful as Harbaugh. Stop.
Did I say he was, or did I say he was a good coach? Love 1 Superbowl loss, Harbaugh 1 super bowl loss. I said Lovie was a good coach also. Harbaugh is over-rated. You disagree, thats fine.
You're putting Lovie and Harbaugh on the same level. Harbaugh has already been to more NFCCG's than Lovie was in 9 years in 4 years of coaching. He only has one fewer 10 win season. I have no idea why you are invoking Smith's name here. Harbaugh has already accomplished more than Smith in 4 seasons than Smith did in 9 years.
Harbaugh is a very good NFL coach. Any Bears fan who doesn't want him coaching this team should be taken out back and beaten over the head.
And how do explain this year in 49ers land? Que up the excuses:
And how do explain this year in 49ers land? Que up the excuses:
It's a down season. Shit happens. The team has been hurt. Kap has been below average. Harbaugh hasn't been able to overcome that to this point. Some things he can't control. Other's he can. I think it's kind of funny though everyone is concentrated on 25% of Harbaugh's NFL coaching career at this point rather than looking at the other 75%. But whatever. Anything it takes to make a Special person argument I suppose.
If you're passing on Harbaugh for no other reason than what has happened this season rather than looking at his full body of work as a coach...well then. Have fun with that I guess. The world needs idiot.