NBA Finals Discussion Thread

Who Wins?


  • Total voters
    18
  • Poll closed .

Scoot26

Administrator
Staff member
Donator
CCS Hall of Fame '20
Joined:
Jun 25, 2010
Posts:
39,766
Liked Posts:
29,901
Another thing to look at considering the Knicks is the historical accuracy of needing a Top 10 offense and defense to go deep. Yes it can be done without it, but way more often than not the teams in the Finals have both, and the winner is all but a little more than a handful of times ranked Top 10 in both.

Those Knicks team never ranked Top 10 in offense during the Riley or Van Gundy years. They came damn close in 1992 though, but were a 4th seed and faced a superior Bulls team (though took them to 7 games) in the 2nd round.

SeasonSeedTeamRecordOff RatDef RatCoachResults
1991-924Knicks51-31112P. RileyL-2nd Rnd vs CHI 4-3
1992-931Knicks60-22221P. RileyL-ECF vs CHI 4-2
1993-942Knicks57-25161P. RileyL-Finals vs HOU 4-3

Concerning Portland meanwhile was Top 10 three years in both categories from 89-92 with two Finals appearances:

SeasonSeedTeamRecordOff RatDef RatCoachResults
1989-903Blazers59-2394R. AdelmanL-Finals vs DET 4-1
1990-911Blazers63-1923R. AdelmanL-WCF vs LAL 4-2
1991-921Blazers57-2573R. AdelmanL-Finals vs CHI 4-2

Kinda easy to see why the Knicks fell short, and while matchups and talent level matter more than these rankings, they do play a role. The offensive fire power who could also play defense usually beat the Knicks, hence their losses to the Bulls numerous times.

And the year the Knicks made the Finals under Riley, in 1994, they faced:
SeedTeamRecOff RatDef RatResults
7Nets45-371310W 3-1
3Bulls55-27146W 4-3
5Pacers47-35118W 4-3
They didn't face any Top 10 offense in those playoffs (as the East had zero that year, and someone had to go to the Finals) and struggled with the Jordan-less Bulls and Reggie Miller that each went 7 games.

Then in the Finals they faced a team very similar to them that also went to down to the wire and a Game 7. A couple of bounces in Game 6 and they probably win, but no such luck. The Rockets ranked 15-2 that year and were helped out a lot by Seattle getting very very upset in the First Round that year.
 
Top