Foreman - 914 yards 4.5 YPC, 3.26 YCO
Monty - 801 yards 4.0 YPC, 2.90 YCO
Herbert - 731 yards 5.7 YPC, 3.67 YCO
Bears have a considerable advantage when it comes to established runners. Gibbs isnt enough to close that gap especially when factoring in Bears also have RoJo.
I also think Gibbs is limited as a runner and his value is moreso in being able to catch so Bears are better in terms of pure running so I lean Bears until Gibbs proves he can be a CMC type performer.
Answer me this, who is the fastest? Defenses will not have to game plan for Foreman or Herbert, while Gibbs will put the fear of god in them. Herbert, Rojo, Foreman, none of those lined up in the slot or out of the backfield as a receiver scare anybody.
Odd how last year you were telling me how much a better back Monty was than Swift, and when I pointed out Swift had more YPC, you said that did not mean anything, now this year it means everything. Talking out of both sides of your mouth again, I see.
You have spent a considerable amount of time telling me the Bears have a better run blocking line than the Lions, let's see what happens to Monty's YPC this year to see how that pans out.
Herbert is so one dimensional, he telegraphs to the defense what the Bears are going to do when he is in. Getting 5.7 YPC when you are used on third and 8 is a win for the defense.
But hey, Bears have a Qb that is a running back, and now they have a Rb that is a QB.
Brilliant!