So your contention is that his inability to throw to first should disqualify him, even though it is rarely a factor in a game.right, and now the discussion is will he be the first pitcher who cannot throw to anything but a catchers mitt be in the hall of fame. With the standards falling has they have, this would put a complete joke wing on that building.
You do realize he allows very few stolen bases, don’t you? Or do you?
That is less a factor than pitchers’ hitting ability, and I know of no sane person that would factor that in.