I have followed Andy Dalton for his entire career. Here is the scoop on Dalton.

CygnusX44

Bulgogi Apparatus
Joined:
Jan 12, 2020
Posts:
683
Liked Posts:
480
Location:
Uranus, MO
I miss Aaronitout. I expect a QB comparison soon.
 

nvanprooyen

Moderator
Staff member
Donator
CCS Hall of Fame '19
Joined:
Apr 4, 2011
Posts:
18,493
Liked Posts:
29,279
Location:
Volusia County, FL
My favorite teams
  1. Chicago Bears
You are getting a very good QB, a GREAT man, a true leader.

Andy Dalton fits in very well with The City of Big Shoulders and how the world views the Chicago Bears franchise. Tough. Strong. Durable. Dependable. WINNER.

Andy is a hyper-accurate QB, primarily in the short to mid-ranges. He has a decent deep ball, not fantastic, but good. He sees the field. He knows the defenses. He is very smart.

He is a very good decision maker. He keeps mistakes to a minimum. He knows when to throw the ball away. He manages the game well.

What does he not do that well? He does not scramble very well. He is not an explosive runner. He is pretty fast, but has no wiggle. "Escapability" is not a strength. He is not a showboat kind of guy, and won't be flexing or screaming or talking trash (if you're looking for that kind thing).

His career at Cincinnati was mixed. It started off awesome. Carson Palmer basically quit the team and Dalton (fresh off of a Rose Bowl win for the TCU Horned Frogs over the Wisconsin Badgers) was thrown into the mix. He didn't even have the opportunity to be the starter in training camp. But he led the team to a winning season and a playoff appearance in his rookie year.

The first five years in Cincinnati were pretty great. He did great things for the franchise. While they went to the playoffs five times in a row under Dalton, he only played in four playoff games. He lost his big chance to win a playoff game in 2015 because he tore a ligament in his thumb right before the playoffs. A. J. McCarron lost that game. That was their best team and Andy's best chance. The first four playoff games were not great by Dalton, but really the team choked as a whole. You may remember that the Bengals were a really punky team in those days, and tons of personal fouls and rotten play, especially on defense, lost many of those games. Dalton played well in two of those games, played average in one, didn't play well in another, and again didn't get to play the fifth.

The next four seasons sucked. Dalton persevered, but the team fell apart. He had no offensive line protection, few good weapons, tons of injuries around him, and a freaking coaching carousel.

The ownership group is terrible in Cinci, and the management is worse. I think Dalton had a different offensive coordinator every year for five or more of his years there. Of course, the fans are also pretty rotten, and Dalton got little support from the carousel of coaches, the management, or the fans.

Despite all that, Dalton put together the longest playoff appearance streak in Bengals history, and holds most of their franchise QB records. He remained durable, consistent, and an altogether good to very good QB during his nine years there. On top of it all, Andy and his wife formed the Andy and JJ Dalton Foundation, and they dedicated significant amounts of time and money to helping families of sick children with their hospital bills and overall quality of life. The big thrust of the foundation is to give fun experiences, date nights, and other social boosts to those grieving families. They have improved tens of thousands of lives with that Foundation. It is truly remarkable, and unusually effective compared to most foundations you see out there. Really a first-rate outfit. Andy and his wife give sacrificially with their money. It's cool to watch.

Dalton's 10th season was with the Cowboys. He did pretty well, but as you know, most of the time he was "protected" by an offensive line made up of second and third teamers. I don't think he had the same line from week to week until near the end of the season. He had no time to throw, and the offensive coordinator Kellen Moore had to revamp the offense to change it to a quick-hitting offense, as Dalton typically had anywhere from 1.8 to 2.3 seconds to get the ball off.

The Head Coach of the Cowboys had nothing but good things to say about Dalton. Here's something cool: Apparently Dalton has kept notebooks of every single team and defensive coordinator he has faced in 10 years in the league. It is a treasure trove of information; schemes, plays that were effective, plays that were not effective, player breakdowns, coaching tendencies, everything. He approaches every game like he is a coach. Consummate professional, very diligent. Nobody works harder. First in the facility in the morning, last to leave.

If you will just give this guy a chance, and an offensive line to give him more than 2.3 seconds to throw the damned ball, Andy Dalton will deliver for you. He is a very good NFL QB, especially if he has a line to protect him. He is not Tom Brady, but he is light years better than Foles, Trubisky, or any of the other knuckleheads that you have been living with for the last 20 years in Chicago.

Last word: I am really excited that Andy is going to Chicago. I have liked the Bears since '85. I really love Chicago as a city. I live in Fort Worth and became a Dalton fan because of TCU. But I will be traveling up there to some games this year. The Bears are about to be the new favorite team in our household.

They don't make better people than the Dalton family. Give this guy a chance, some line protection, and some support, and he will make you proud.
I want to believe
 

bears51/40

Well-known member
Joined:
Aug 21, 2012
Posts:
4,356
Liked Posts:
3,342
the deeper thing is....when we get a new GM & HC, we need someone with both success & experience. For me, I never expected much from Pace/Nagy. They came to us with no success & experience as GM & HC.
Get used to the idea of Pace/Nagy for at least two more years after the Bears use a high draft pick for the QB of the future.
 

94c4lt1

CCS Donator
Donator
Joined:
Aug 20, 2012
Posts:
5,950
Liked Posts:
3,864
If you followed the model of mediocrity, wrapped in freckled alabaster skin and glazed with fire-engine red hair, his entire career then you deserve to miserable with all us Bears fans as well. Welcome aboard.

christmas-vacation-national-lampoons-griswolds-clark-griswold-chevy-chase-gif-4838086.gif
 

run and shoot

Well-known member
Joined:
Apr 28, 2013
Posts:
16,007
Liked Posts:
3,263
My favorite teams
  1. Chicago Bulls
  1. Chicago Bears
  1. Illinois Fighting Illini
the deeper thing is....when we get a new GM & HC, we need someone with both success & experience. For me, I never expected much from Pace/Nagy. They came to us with no success & experience as GM & HC.


Get used to the idea of Pace/Nagy for at least two more years after the Bears use a high draft pick for the QB of the future.

I'm thinking dalton gonna get both Pace/Nagy fired. Just like he got Lewis fired.
 

run and shoot

Well-known member
Joined:
Apr 28, 2013
Posts:
16,007
Liked Posts:
3,263
My favorite teams
  1. Chicago Bulls
  1. Chicago Bears
  1. Illinois Fighting Illini
In $$$ money games this guy is a choker. I'm NOT drinking the " Dalton acceptance kool aid". I'm sure I'll be hated for not going along with this b.s. signing.


Dalton........
View attachment 10779

the deeper thing is....when we get a new GM & HC, we need someone with both success & experience. For me, I never expected much from Pace/Nagy. They came to us with no success & experience as GM & HC.

Get used to the idea of Pace/Nagy for at least two more years after the Bears use a high draft pick for the QB of the future.

I'm thinking dalton gonna get both Pace/Nagy fired. Just like he got Lewis fired.

Marvin Lewis got Marvin Lewis fired

The numbers in dalton's 0-4 playoff background don't lie. One Td vs 6 ints over 4 playoff games. Lewis fell on the sword for that performance. You know what I say, show me a "bad HC" and I'll show u his bad Qb

1616032509642.png
 

greg23

Well-known member
Joined:
Sep 28, 2014
Posts:
8,568
Liked Posts:
4,677
When Andy Dalton was good; he was average.

I'm hoping for more/better moves but fully expect a non-athletic, noodle armed qb room of:

Fools
Dalton
Trash
 

Akuma2000

CCS Donator
Donator
Joined:
Aug 5, 2011
Posts:
1,116
Liked Posts:
150
Location:
Sweet Home Chicago
Yeah I get it. But from where I sit, it seems the Bears are rebuilding, and getting a stud like Wilson would have cost so much money and draft picks, you'd be set back for years. I think Dalton is a decent fit here, if you are trying to reverse a negative culture and build a winning culture. Spend your draft picks wisely, bring in some offensive linemen in free agency, and you've got something.

Agreed.

Use those draft picks to build up the O-line with some depth to at least give Dalton a chance at sustaining drives by being able to throw the ball, also draft some more wide receivers for him to throw to (gotta replace Allen Robinson and Anthony Miller).

I hope Dalton does well this upcoming season.
 
Last edited:

LiverpoolBearsFAn

Well-known member
Joined:
Dec 16, 2014
Posts:
971
Liked Posts:
751
Location:
Liverpool, England
Thanks OP for all the information!

It makes me feel more positive.

I’ll be pulling for Andy Dalton come the start of the season. I think he will be an upgrade and it’s nice to know he is a good human being.
 

Adipost

CCS Donator
Donator
Joined:
Sep 28, 2014
Posts:
8,616
Liked Posts:
10,212
Location:
Chicago, IL
When Andy Dalton was good; he was average.

I'm hoping for more/better moves but fully expect a non-athletic, noodle armed qb room of:

Fools
Dalton
Trash

When Dalton was “good“, the offense was absolutely stacked. For a 2-3 year window around 2015, the Bengals had the best roster in the league. Top offensive line, great Wr’s, good defense, and he still couldn’t even sniff a playoff win. The one time the Bengals actually almost pulled off a playoff win was with AJ Mckraken at QB.

Now Dalton is older, lost some of his athleticism which was one of his few positives, and is in a much worse situation. This is gonna be ugly.
 
Last edited:

pfcmsh

Active member
Joined:
Nov 15, 2015
Posts:
585
Liked Posts:
154
Location:
Northern Illinois
Anybody is better than who we had a Q last year. I'm optimistic. Any QB we have is only as good as the offensive line and surrounding cast and let's not forget that Nagy talks a good gam, but can't deliver a good offensive plan. I think Dalton can help the growth of a newly drafted QB.
 

Leomaz

Pissing people off the right way!
Donator
Joined:
Jul 15, 2012
Posts:
14,948
Liked Posts:
5,696
Location:
In the stratosphere
My favorite teams
  1. Chicago White Sox
  1. Chicago Bulls
  1. Chicago Bears
  1. Chicago Blackhawks
  1. Indiana Hoosiers
  2. Notre Dame Fighting Irish
When Dalton was “good“, the offense was absolutely stacked. For a 2-3 year window around 2015, the Bengals had the best roster in the league. Top offensive line, great Wr’s, good defense, and he still couldn’t even sniff a playoff win. The one time the Bengals actually almost pulled off a playoff win was with AJ Mckraken at QB.

Now Dalton is older, lost some of his athleticism which was one of his few positives, and is in a much worse situation. This is gonna be ugly.
I’m gonna go out on a limb here and say that the Bengals during the first 5 years of the Andy Dalton era never had the “best roster” in the whole NFL.
 

Top