I've compared the stats and.... are you serious...??? As far as checking down.. the biggest difference between the two... and this is what ultimately handicapped Orton as a QB... he checked down because he couldn't make the downfield throw vs. checking down because it was the safe completion. He threw and completed more passes past 30 yards in limited play his first two seasons... than Orton did with two full seasons as a Bear. His stats as a rookie dominate any season Orton had as a Bear... accuracy... YPP... TDs.
He has terrible pocket presence and the mobility of a slug. When he is forced off his spot, which will be often, his accuracy plummets.
He's slow, did I mention he was slow, oh yeah he has a slow release. this is his clone Oh Jonathan Quinn
http://www.ranker.com/list/all-chicago-bears-starting-quarterbacks/phoenixd112
Another comparison based on what..... height? Because thats where the comparison ends. Nothing else is similar about him and Quinn. Quinn was horrible... his stats prove he was horrible... he never showed anything to suggest he had a remote chance to be good.
Some of his play was consistent with him being a rookie when he got most of his play...... most rookies have issues handling pressure.... looking bad for complete halfs.... etc.... they all do. Citing bad habits which are typical of rookie players and can be coached out.... are not really fair criticism.
When i've looked at every video of his plays... I don't see the clumsy, slow release a few people have mentioned. He's not Wilson quick behind the line... though he may lack athleticism... he looks like a typical pocket passer.
I've watched whatever videos I could from his play with TB showing both the good and the bad.... but I just don't see much to support of these type of complaints.
[video=youtube;7hK8tCsYRq4]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7hK8tCsYRq4[/video]