That wouldn't be NFL+. It would be NFL+ premium, a different package. Football's not the type game people want to wait to watch a replay of. I'd pay for the Premium if it was as the Sunday ticket was but it's nothing like that. Would think the NFL could make a lot more money if they did that Sunday Ticket style through their streaming service. Could hit a much wider market, being all inclusive and not just applicable to those who get DirectTV or Apple or Amazon when they sell it to them. And there's still the obvious fact that you can find free streams of any game.
The replays and all 22 for $9.99 seems like a pretty good deal if you have the time to vest in that. The $79.99 per year seems like a waste as the regular season is only 4 months long and that $80 price tag far exceeds the amount you'd be paying by the month, unless you're really crazy invested in the all 22 and replays and want to still be watching them in the coming summer months.
Yeah, that's why I put the premium after the $80. So, NFL+ premium is basically what NFL Game pass used to be.
If you don't want any of the game replays, then heck yeah, the $40 ($30 now for early access) makes a ton of sense.
For me, and again, I am out of market, I really did actually like the ad-free condensed game replay to be able to see the game. But that is obviously going to vary from person to person. The condensed one made it so you could watch the game in under an hour.
As far as the $9.99/month vs $79.99/yr goes, I look at it as I would be using it for probably at least a solid 6 months now (Aug-Jan). For $20 more, I get it year round and I don't have to remember to cancel it. Just pay it the once and done. Again, to each their own.