Roquan Smith trade offer

[iueyedoc]

So several other teams Daniel Sigler's are proposing trades for Noshowquan.

Which would be your choice:

A:


B:


C:

D:


E:

Oh, and this Cleaveland Browns website name is hilarious:

 

[Dejo]

Some of those are god awful. I’ll take Claypool and a second tho

 

[ZOMBIE@CTESPN]

A or C the rest are meh

 

[bamainatlanta]

A or E. Hard pass on the others.

 

[remydat]

A or D. Doubt Steelers resign Claypool so moving him makes sense. Question is whether they want to give an off ball LB 20m+

 

[Montucky]

If the Bears were certian they could lock up Da'Ron Payne on a relatively fair team-friendly deal I would be most keen on that one.

These are all very pretty generous I feel like. If the Browns would bump that 2024 second to a 2023 second (and just drop Kareem Hunt all together since the Bears will never approve of him on the team) it would be the next best after option E. All the Steelers offers are intriguing in their own way, but I think I'd rather have the first rounder than have Chase Claypool personally.

 

[dennehy]

Payne fills a huge need, is versatile and has missed one game in the whole career I think. He's a sure bet but would cost close to as much as Roq.

 

[Montucky]

Payne fills a huge need, is versatile and has missed one game in the whole career I think. He's a sure bet but would cost close to as much as Roq.

I don't know why the Redskins would make that deal. Plus give up a third rond pick? Thier fans are overrating Roquan Smith a little bit.

 

[FozzyBear]

none of those trades, but All the picks..

 

[dennehy]

I don't know why the Redskins would make that deal. Plus give up a third rond pick? Thier fans are overrating Roquan Smith a little bit.

I haven't followed but he's on his 5th year option and maybe there is some animosity?

They have a lot of good DL but I think you're right that him and a third sounds a bit much.

 

[Bronek]

Trade Smith for O Linemen. We need help there, the wide receiver wont help if Fields is on his back.

 

[Montucky]

I haven't followed but he's on his 5th year option and maybe there is some animosity?

They have a lot of good DL but I think you're right that him and a third sounds a bit much.

Yeah I suppose they already have Chase Young, Montez Sweat and Jonathan Allen. Can't afford all those guys, let alone also Da'Ron Payne.

But its a pretty astute call from an opposing fanbase recognizing what is low-key one of the Bears most pretty needs. Even if it is a little out-of-town stupid in its generosity.

 

[nvanprooyen]

So several other teams Daniel Sigler's are proposing trades for Noshowquan.

Which would be your choice:

A:
View attachment 21717

B:
View attachment 21718

C:
View attachment 21720
D:
View attachment 21721

E:
View attachment 21722
Oh, and this Cleaveland Browns website name is hilarious:
View attachment 21719

Re the factory of sadness thing, that was a classic. Came from this:

Relatable.

 

[BeerFan]

IMO, the Bears are not trading Roquan this season. He will be playing under his existing contract this year. If he continues to play well in the new defensive scheme, I can see them extending him before years end (being a reasonable contract of which Roquan will not sign). Then the Bears have franchise tag they can use then sign / trade him.

I would love for Roquan to continue as a Bear. If not, leverage the hell out of him and make a trade for at least a top player and/or at least a 1st round pick.

 

[botfly10]

Is it just me that feels like most of these offers are overvaluing Smith?

I mean I sort of don't see Quan garnering a first in trade, let alone a first and then some

 

[iueyedoc]

Yeah I suppose they already have Chase Young, Montez Sweat and Jonathan Allen. Can't afford all those guys, let alone also Da'Ron Payne.

But its a pretty astute call from an opposing fanbase recognizing what is low-key one of the Bears most pretty needs. Even if it is a little out-of-town stupid in its generosity.

Payne fills a huge need, is versatile and has missed one game in the whole career I think. He's a sure bet but would cost close to as much as Roq.

Agreed, I would like this trade, and paying a high end DT $17-20M for this defense is way more critical than a high end Will.

 

[ZOMBIE@CTESPN]

Is it just me that feels like most of these offers are overvaluing Smith?

I mean I sort of don't see Quan garnering a first in trade, let alone a first and then some

I can’t see a lb being flipped for a dline. But any team that thinks they have their qb already I can see a first for smith.

 

[iueyedoc]

Is it just me that feels like most of these offers are overvaluing Smith?

I mean I sort of don't see Quan garnering a first in trade, let alone a first and then some

I think the Redski...Commanders trade seems the most realistic. They have a shit ton of DLmen that they can't pay and could use a LB. Even straight up without the 3rd/4th rnd pick this would likely improve both teams.

 

[Chicago4Life]

So several other teams Daniel Sigler's are proposing trades for Noshowquan.

Which would be your choice:

A:
View attachment 21717

B:
View attachment 21718

C:
View attachment 21720
D:
View attachment 21721

E:
View attachment 21722
Oh, and this Cleaveland Browns website name is hilarious:
View attachment 21719

i would take E as i dont think the steelers have the current/future cap space to give roquan the deal he wants

 

[Enasic]

A