Who's going to be the best NFL QB from this draft?

[SD Bears]

Consensus:
2017 - Mahomes
2018 - Allen
2019 - Murray in a dog shit draft class
2020 - Likely Burrow or Herbert but too soon to tell
2021 - Prepare to be necro'd

My pre-draft picks were/are:
2017 - Watson (nope)
2018 - Mayfield (close, no cigar)
2019 - Murray
2020 - Burrow
2021 - Wilson

 

[Rise]

I’ll stick with Lawrence.

 

[Black Rainbow]

Lawrence and Fields are the real NFL caliber QBs - the rest are going to be over drafted.

 

[Montucky]

I voted Trey Lance because if he hits he's going to hit big. Mac Jones would be the next best. I think Lawrence will be overall quite the disappointment.

 

[SD Bears]

I voted Trey Lance because if he hits he's going to hit big. Mac Jones would be the next best. I think Lawrence will be overall quite the disappointment.

I agree with Jones, especially if he ends up with the Pats

 

[HeHateMe]

I voted Trey Lance because if he hits he's going to hit big. Mac Jones would be the next best. I think Lawrence will be overall quite the disappointment.

BUT DOES ANY OF THAT EVEN MATTER BECAUSE QB'S DON'T WIN SUPER BOWLS

 

[Bearly]

If I said, not who you think. I'd probably be right 80% of the time in this draft. I'd guess Wilson but have very little confidence in that.

 

[ZOMBIE@CTESPN]

Based on talent I think fields

based on team I’m saying whoever 49ers pick

 

[BaBaBlacksheep]

BUT DOES ANY OF THAT EVEN MATTER BECAUSE QB'S DON'T WIN SUPER BOWLS

Excellent point! I mean if you look up winners of prior Super Bowls do you see Brett Favre? Aaron Rodgers? Tom Brady?

Of course not!! They give Super Bowls to teams. So thank you for your excellent point. QB's DON'T WIN SUPER BOWLS.

 

[Montucky]

BUT DOES ANY OF THAT EVEN MATTER BECAUSE QB'S DON'T WIN SUPER BOWLS

 

[HeHateMe]

View attachment 11437

@nvanprooyen

 

[TezMaKai]

Fields, and it's not even close.

 

[JesusHalasChrist]

We'll be able to rule one of them out if the Bears take one.

 

[SD Bears]

Based on talent I think fields

based on team I’m saying whoever 49ers pick

If they trade up, it'll be interesting to see what Belichick / McDaniels can do with Fields, Lance, or Jones.

 

[Montucky]

Consensus:
2017 - Mahomes
2018 - Allen
2019 - Murray in a dog shit draft class
2020 - Likely Burrow or Herbert but too soon to tell
2021 - Prepare to be necro'd

My pre-draft picks were/are:
2017 - Watson (nope)
2018 - Mayfield (close, no cigar)
2019 - Murray
2020 - Burrow
2021 - Wilson

Also, are we all sure Josh Allen is better than Lamar Jackson? I actually dont think particularly highly of either but I just shake the sense that the bottom is going to fall out of Allen sooner than later. He doesn't feel real. I also think Kyler Murray kinda blows, but he's stuck with an idiot head coach that is perhaps even worse than Matt Nagy.

Also Baker Mayfield is closer to being out of the league than he is to being in the realm of Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson. I know was burying those guys just a paragraph ago but Mayfield truly is abysmal.

 

[aeronaut]

Not that I or many others would have voted for him, but you might have wanted to include Trask in the poll, possibly Newman too. Maybe there's a number of choices limitation, I don't know.

 

[SD Bears]

Also, are we all sure Josh Allen is better than Lamar Jackson? I actually dont think particularly highly of either but I just shake the sense that the bottom is going to fall out of Allen sooner than later. He doesn't feel real. I also think Kyler Murray kinda blows, but he's stuck with an idiot head coach that is perhaps even worse than Matt Nagy.

Also Baker Mayfield is closer to being out of the league than he is to being in the realm of Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson. I know was burying those guys just a paragraph ago but Mayfield truly is abysmal.

Right now he is, but it's definitely fair to say the 2018 class has not been fully decided. Also, Mayfield is not trash. It's hard to find a 2020 ranking that has him lower than 12. I didn't find one but I'm sure it's out there.

 

[SD Bears]

Not that I or many others would have voted for him, but you might have wanted to include Trask in the poll, possibly Newman too. Maybe there's a number of choices limitation, I don't know.

Because nobody except maybe my 6 year old daughter would select either of them

 

[hyatt151]

I went with Lawrence,but Fields is my strong 2nd choice