dougthonus wrote:
The thing with all of those points, except the Vinny Johnson one, are based in fact even if they are exaggerated.
He is short.
He doesn't play good defense.
He does frequently dominate the ball for long stretch of the shot clock trying to go isolation on someone and forcing up a bad jumper (ie selfish)
Throughout his career, he has been inconsistent
He does shoot one of the highest volumes of shot per minute in the nba (shoots too much)
So while I think a detailed debate about those things and how important they are is possible, and I'm not sure how important these flaws are, by just naming them off as "cliche" things people say doesn't make them all irrelevant all of a sudden.
There is somewhere between a little and a lot of truth with all of those points.
You're right, these are legitimate points, but each one is made out to be waaay more than it seems. He's a bit short for his position and that causes his defense to suffer a little. Those two points are actually the same point in a way. he does a decnet job considering his height disadvantage, especially since he's very strong and reasonably quick and has shown commitment to get better on defense over time.
He's a scorer, of course he has the ball in his hands a lot. Often it's by design from the coaching staff. Can't fault the guy for doing what he's asked to do.
I don't know how you measure consistency in the NBA, everyone goes through slumps and hot streaks, Players play better when they're fully healthy and worse when they have nagging injuries (and we don't hear about every minor ding that players have so sometimes there's a real injury going on but fans complain that "he's not trying" or "he's in a slump.") I think "inconsistent" is kind of a myth. How the heck do you measure it? But OK, fine, for the sake of the argument he's a bit inconsistent.
I don't know how the player woith one of the highest true shooting percentages on a team can ever be said to "shoot too much" especially if he's generally getting himself open to get his shots off. Gordan shoots a lot, but it's in the flow of the offense or at the end of games as a closer wher the coaches don't trust other players in the clutch.
So I would argue that these are not so much flaws in his game as simply his "style of play" which has strengths and weaknesses just like every player. And if they are "flaws," then he must be extremely good at his strengths if he was the best player on the team for the past several seasons.