CHICITYSPORTS – Chicago Sports  Blog – News – Forum – Rumors – Fans
  • BEARS
  • BULLS
  • BLACKHAWKS
  • CUBS
  • WHITE SOX
  • MESSAGE BOARD
Navigation
  • About Us
  • Chicago Sports Podcasts
  • ChiCity+
  • CHICITYSPORTS – Chicago Sports Blog – News – Forum – Rumors – Fans
  • Get In Touch
  • Join Our Group
  • Newsletter
  • Our Writers
  • Privacy Policy
  • Want to Write for ChiCitySports?
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending
  • Former Chicago Bears DB signs deal with Raiders
  • Notre Dame lands underrated coach in Micah Shrewsberry
  • BREAKING: Chicago Bears sign former Tennessee Titans linebacker
  • Don’t miss the opportunity to use Melbet promo code
  • Chicago Bears’ get early win over Green Bay Packers in offseason
  • Report: Chicago Bears Insider suggests teams plans for Teven Jenkins
  • Chicago Bears named ‘best fit’ for electric All-Pro offensive weapon
  • Best Chicago Sports Gear For This Spring and Summer from FOCO
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Our Writers
  • Want to Write for ChiCitySports?
CHICITYSPORTS – Chicago Sports  Blog – News – Forum – Rumors – FansCHICITYSPORTS – Chicago Sports  Blog – News – Forum – Rumors – Fans
  • BEARS

    Former Chicago Bears DB signs deal with Raiders

    March 23, 2023

    BREAKING: Chicago Bears sign former Tennessee Titans linebacker

    March 23, 2023

    Chicago Bears’ get early win over Green Bay Packers in offseason

    March 22, 2023

    Report: Chicago Bears Insider suggests teams plans for Teven Jenkins

    March 22, 2023

    Chicago Bears named ‘best fit’ for electric All-Pro offensive weapon

    March 22, 2023
  • BULLS

    Bulls’ guard Lonzo Ball undergoing third surgery, could miss 2023-24 season

    March 16, 2023

    Zach LaVine not letting Bulls go quietly

    March 12, 2023

    Bulls’ Lonzo Ball may need third surgery on knee

    March 9, 2023

    The Air Jordan 4 is next to get the ‘reimagined’ treatment in 2024

    March 2, 2023

    Goran Dragic’s time with the Bulls has ended

    February 28, 2023
  • BLACKHAWKS

    BREAKING: Chicago Blackhawks trade Patrick Kane

    February 28, 2023

    Chicago Blackhawks hit win streak in the month of February 2023

    February 22, 2023

    Comparing the Dynamic of Two Rebuilding Clubs

    January 25, 2023

    Chicago Fans’ One Wish for Every Team in 2023

    December 31, 2022

    Blackhawks’ Sam Lafferty returns to line-up vs. Jets

    December 9, 2022
  • CUBS

    Javier Assad dominated a stacked USA lineup

    March 13, 2023

    Mike Tauchman impressing early on for Chicago Cubs

    March 8, 2023

    Willson Contreras takes shot at Chicago Cubs

    February 25, 2023

    Cubs reportedly add reliever Michael Fulmer

    February 10, 2023

    Chicago Cubs still sculpting their bullpen

    January 17, 2023
  • WHITE SOX

    Chicago White Sox agree to terms with Elvis Andrus

    February 20, 2023

    Chicago White Sox 2023 prospect watch: outfielder Oscar Colas

    January 18, 2023

    Chicago Fans’ One Wish for Every Team in 2023

    December 31, 2022

    MLB analyst pitches insane White Sox Yankees trade

    December 22, 2022

    Outfielder Andrew Benintendi signs with White Sox

    December 16, 2022
  • MESSAGE BOARD
Facebook Twitter Instagram
CHICITYSPORTS – Chicago Sports  Blog – News – Forum – Rumors – Fans
Home»Bears»In Defense of Jon Gruden
Bears

In Defense of Jon Gruden

Z PBy Z PJune 22, 20134 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Reddit Tumblr Email
original
original
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

Michael David Smith at profootballtalk.com describes comments that Packers quarterback Aaron Rogers made via Twitter during the NBA Finals. One of those comments took Magic Johnson to task for his almost entirely positive commentary on individual players and, as he did it, Rogers also took a back handed swipe at Monday Night Footballcommentator Jon Gruden:

Magic is quickly becoming the John Gruden of ESPN NBA coverage. Everybody is the greatest everything. #bedtime

— Aaron Rodgers (@AaronRodgers12) June 21, 2013

Smith seems to agree:

I don’t watch enough of ESPN’s NBA coverage to know if Rodgers’ criticism of Johnson is valid, but I do agree with Rodgers that Gruden can be so relentlessly positive about every player that his analysis becomes pointless: When you call every player great it can serve to diminish the players who are truly great. Perhaps that’s why it took a truly great player to call Gruden out.

This is a surprisingly shallow comment from the usually thoughtful Smith. It reflects comments that I frequently hear after writing up my “Game Comments” after Bears games during the season. I usually devote at least one line to how I thought the television commentators did if I watched the game at home. This single entry draws more comments from people than almost anything else I typically address in the post. Like Johnson and Gruden, most people think I’m “relentlessly positive” in my comments.

There are a couple reasons for this. First, the Bears play a lot of night games and when they aren’t in prime time, they often get an afternoon slot where much of the country sees them. What that means is that the Bears naturally have been getting the best football commentators available for their games. If you were to look back into the history of this blog into some of those darker years where the Bears weren’t very good, you’d see many more critical comments as they drew the fourth or fifth announcing teams.

However, its the other reason that’s relevant here. I think many fans have a warped idea of just what constitutes a good color commentator for a football game, indeed for any sport. These men really aren’t there just to hammer on players for bad play. In fact, in my opinion, its the least of their duties. As a research scientist one thing became clear to me very early on in my career: any moron can criticize. You can always tell when comments on your work came from a young investigator in training because they pick on things that everyone knows are a problem but which few people think are a real obstacles to supporting a particular conclusion. The trick is to recognize when its appropriate to both listen to and offer a critical comment (i.e. when the criticism is important) and when its not. In the case of football players, everyone – even the best of them – makes mistakes. We all know that. For that reason whatever criticism a good commentator offers on individual players is usually in terms of individual technique. Beyond that, frankly, if Gruden isn’t too free with his critical comments, he’ll hear few complaints from me. I don’t care if he says if a player is great or isn’t great. I can usually see that with my own eyes.

What really makes for a top notch commentator – what really makes the difference between a Cris Collinsworth and some schlub off of a local television station somewhere – is the ability of the person involved to teach the viewer about the game. This is where Gruden excels. He’s always going to be the guy to notice some little point about how the defense is playing, where the mismatches are or where the offense is attacking in a particularly notable way. Almost all fans are limited by the fact that they aren’t good enough to actually get on the field and do the things that NFL football players do. We can’t go to mini-camp and learn about the ins and out of the cover two defense. Its these comments from the likes of Gruden and Collinsworth that are so valuable because they increase understanding of a game we all love and would like to know better but where opportunities to do so are limited.

This is far more important than criticizing the play of individuals because those types of comments die after the game is over or after the player involved is no longer on the field. In contrast, the lessons taught about how the game is played last a lifetime and whatever criticism we, ourselves, offer should be targeted with that in mind.

For More Great Chicago Sports Content

Follow us on Twitter at @chicitysports23 for more great content. We appreciate you taking time to read our articles. To interact more with our community and keep up to date on the latest in Chicago sports news, JOIN OUR FREE FACEBOOK GROUP by CLICKING HERE

FEATURED
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Tumblr Email
The Worst Things Bart Simpson Has Ever Done Ranked
Z P
  • Twitter

Chicago sports.

Related Posts

Bears March 23, 2023

Former Chicago Bears DB signs deal with Raiders

Bears March 23, 2023

BREAKING: Chicago Bears sign former Tennessee Titans linebacker

Bears March 22, 2023

Chicago Bears’ get early win over Green Bay Packers in offseason

Bears March 22, 2023

Report: Chicago Bears Insider suggests teams plans for Teven Jenkins

Bears March 22, 2023

Chicago Bears named ‘best fit’ for electric All-Pro offensive weapon

Bears March 22, 2023

REPORT: Bears will be at 2023 Ohio State Pro Day; could be scouting massive offensive tackle

Leave A Reply

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

Team Message Boards

bears TP
bulls TP
cubs TP
sox TP
hawks TP
we want you to write
Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube
  • Home
  • Message Board
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Our Writers
  • Want to Write for ChiCitySports?
© 2023 ChiCitySports. Designed by Dope Guys Who Run ChiCitySports.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.